
I had the opportunity to watch the recent exchange at the White House between Donald Trump and the President of South Africa, which was broadcast yesterday.
The scene prompted me to write the following post — composed ex tempore, in direct response to what I observed.
Populist politics does not rely solely on lies or outdated arguments.
More subtly, it often distorts opposing views through the use of strawman arguments: simplified or exaggerated versions of the other side’s position, easy to attack and dismiss.
By knocking down a flimsy caricature rather than addressing the real issue, the populist turns negotiation into a zero-sum game: one side wins only if the other is forced to lose.
The goal is not agreement, but imposition—through rhetorical force, emotional appeal, or outright pressure.
Yet such victories are short-lived.
Agreements based on distortion or coercion are inherently unstable.
The moment the disadvantaged party can walk away, it will.
The steel man argument offers an alternative path.
It involves presenting your counterpart’s position in its strongest, most coherent form—sometimes even improving it—before offering critique.
This approach fosters trust, recognises shared interests, and leads to agreements that are more likely to endure over time.
Here is how these two approaches manifest at each stage of a negotiation:
- Preparation and Framing
Strawman
- Tactic: Misrepresenting the opposing position from the outset to justify a rigid stance.
- Effect: Provokes antagonism and narrows the scope for empathy.
- Example: “They will demand the impossible—we must hold the line.”
Steel man
- Tactic: Anticipating the other side’s reasoning with fairness and nuance.
- Effect: Encourages foresight and constructive framing.
- Example: “They are likely worried about risk—we can factor that into our offer.”
- Exchange of Positions
Strawman
- Tactic: Framing the other’s proposal as extreme or unreasonable.
- Effect: Escalates mistrust, blocks dialogue.
- Example: “You want all the benefits while we take all the risk?”
Steel man
- Tactic: Rephrasing the other’s view in a clear, reasonable light.
- Effect: Creates room for discussion.
- Example: “If I understand correctly, your focus is cost stability. That is valid.”
- Bargaining and Proposals
Strawman
- Tactic: Miscasting the offer to stir alarm.
- Effect: Reduces the ‘zone of possible agreement’ (ZOPA).
- Example: “Accepting this clause means giving them total control.”
Steel man
- Tactic: Highlighting logic in the proposal to build bridges.
- Effect: Expands the ZOPA through shared interest.
- Example: “Their request shows commitment—can we use this to negotiate better terms?”
- Closing and Agreement
Strawman
- Tactic: Framing final objections as obstinacy.
- Effect: May rush the deal, but erodes goodwill.
- Example: “You are blocking progress over details.”
Steel man
- Tactic: Validating final concerns to reach mutual closure.
- Effect: Enhances long-term trust and satisfaction.
- Example: “Your concern is fair—let us add a review clause to ensure balance.”
Conclusion
Strawman tactics may win headlines or quick concessions, but they undermine durable cooperation.
Steel man strategies require discipline and openness, but they build trust—and trust is the foundation of any lasting agreement.
In serious negotiations, strength lies not in distortion, but in understanding.